Transforming Tradition

Research-based Tools for Strengthening Church Engagement and Authenticity

Listening to why people disengage—and what helps them re-engage with meaning.

Across traditions, church leaders are asking the same question:

Why are people stepping away—and what would make staying possible?

We asked 2,000 adults (ages 18–44).
We listened carefully.

What we heard was not hostility toward faith, but a longing for belonging, integrity, and spiritual growth.

The Study

We asked 2,000 young adults why they left church – and what would make them more engaged. Here is what they said.

This research is grounded in national survey data and qualitative responses from adults ages 18–44 across diverse denominational backgrounds.

The findings challenge common assumptions.

Disengagement is not primarily about theology.
It is not primarily about politics.
It is not primarily about disbelief.

It is about belonging. Trust. And whether churches feel aligned with the values they proclaim.

Life changes and lack of belonging are the top reasons people leave the church.

When people step away, it is most often during major life transitions—moves, marriages, parenting, career shifts.

But underneath those transitions is something deeper:
Many never felt meaningfully known or integrated to begin with.

Belonging—not belief—is the strongest predictor of continued engagement.

Many are open to returning.

Despite headlines about decline, a significant number of respondents expressed openness to joining a church or becoming more involved.

The desire for community remains strong.

The question is whether churches feel like places where people can enter honestly.

Nearly half report having no resources for spiritual growth.

The spiritual hunger is real.

But many do not know where to turn—or do not feel supported in their growth.

People are not rejecting faith.

They are asking for guidance, depth, and trustworthy leadership.

Schedule a Conversation →

If these findings resonate with what you are seeing in your context, we would welcome a conversation.

Download the Full Report →

Get the full picture of why people disengage – and what helps them re-engage with meaning.

What we heard.

Across surveys and focus groups, seven themes consistently shaped people’s church experiences:

1. A Deep Hunger for Real Community

In an increasingly lonely and emotionally strained culture, people are longing for genuine relationships—not programs, but meaningful connection.

2. Service Builds Trust

Churches that serve their communities in tangible, no-strings-attached ways generate openness and credibility far more than those focused primarily on internal activities.

3. Trust Has Been Wounded

Concerns about money, power, transparency, and honesty have deeply damaged institutional trust—yet many remain open to repair when integrity is evident.

4. Belonging Must Be Unconditional

People step away when belonging feels contingent on identity, sexuality, appearance, beliefs, or unspoken cultural expectations.

5. Spiritual Seeking Has Not Disappeared

Many continue to seek meaning and spiritual growth—but often on more flexible, personal, and less institutionally bound terms.

6. Structures Feel Out of Sync

Leadership models, participation expectations, and inherited church structures often feel misaligned with contemporary life, especially for younger generations.

7. Humility Invites; Certainty Repels

Humility, openness, and curiosity are increasingly seen as signs of faithfulness, while politicized or certainty-driven postures push many away.

Taken together, these findings suggest that the challenge facing churches today is about belonging, trust, and lived credibility. What we heard is not a rejection of faith, but a plea for a church worthy of people’s trust, presence, and hope again.

Why This Matters Now

Churches are navigating cultural complexity, political polarization, and institutional decline narratives.

But the research suggests something more hopeful:

People are not asking churches to become less faithful.
They are asking churches to become more trustworthy, more relational, and more aligned with their own stated values.

This moment calls for listening.
For adaptation, not abandonment.
For courage shaped by humility.

How We Support Leaders

We work with:

Engagements include:

Each engagement is tailored, but grounded in the data.

We do not offer silver bullets.
We help leaders discern faithful next steps.

Schedule a Conversation

If these findings resonate with what you are seeing in your context, invite us to work with your leadership team:

Download the Full Report

Get the full picture of why people disengage – and what helps them re-engage with meaning. Enter you info below to download the report: